Call Us: 419-371-4745
435 S Eastown Rd, Lima OH
Hours of Operation:
Tues-Fri 9am-7pm
Sat 9am-4pm

General FAQ's


How should I store my cupcakes? How long will my cupcakes last?

Please store your cupcakes at room temperature; NEVER put them in the refrigerator. Because we bake with fresh ingredients, your cupcakes are best enjoyed within 1-2 days of purchase. If you need to store them longer, transfer them to an airtight container and store in the freezer.

How many people do your cakes serve?

6-inch round ($22) serves 6-8 people.
9-inch round ($32) serves 12-14 people

Are any of your cupcakes allergen-friendly?

Gluten-free cupcakes are available every Thursday in the display, and are also available by special order with a minimum of 1 dozen.

We do not currently carry any dairy-free or sugar-free options. We do have nut-free products available daily.

However, please keep in mind that we are NOT a gluten-free or nut-free facility. We process gluten and nut products on a daily basis, and although we wash & sanitize our equipment in between uses, we do share baking equipment across all products.

When should I pre-order my sweets?

You should preorder if:
* you need several dozen items
* you need a cake
* you need mini cupcakes

How far in advance do I need to pre-order?

We recommend ordering cakes and mini cupcakes with a minimum 2 business days' notice.

If you're in a bind, and need something quick, don't hesitate to ask. If we can squeeze it in, we will!

Please remember that this is a guideline, not a guarantee. We accommodate as many orders as we can, but are limited to what our bakers can physically produce. We DO book up, especially on weekends. In general, the more notice we have, the better.

Can the cupcakes be custom-decorated to match the theme of my wedding?

Of course! Different flavors of cupcakes can be frosted uniformly, and the icing can even be dyed to match your wedding colors. (For best results, please give a swatch of the color you have in mind. Also, keep in mind that dark colors such as black & navy are not a great idea. Your guests will end up with crazy-colored teeth!) If you would like extra décor, such as special sprinkles, designs, or garnishes, there could be an extra fee depending on the cost of the item.

What about delivery and set-up?

Cupcakes can be delivered and set up in Lima for a fee of $50. Delivery and set-up outside of Lima is priced based on location; please inquire for more details. If you would rather pick up your cupcakes, that is fine. Keep in mind that you will need to set up the tower and display. (Aunts and/or cousins are perfect for this!)

Can we have a tasting?

Of course! After arranging with me, you are welcome to pick up a complimentary half-dozen cupcakes from the bakery. You may choose a variety from what is available that day. If there's a very specific flavor you'd like to try, let me know and I can try to work it into the menu.
To find out the Baker's Choice flavors of the day, give us a call at 419-371-4745